I've had good luck with regular spray-can paint. One of the companies, Krylon?, has a Fusor line that is supposedly formulated for plastics.
Preparation is the key to good results. a good scrubbing with soap and water followed by scuffing the surface with fine sandpaper or scotch brite pad should do it.
For console restoration where you do not need to change the color, rubbing compound and wax will bring the shine back out of the plastic.
If the console (late 66, 67) or consolette has a textured finish, prep by scrubbing with Bon Ami or Comet/Ajax and a brush....it'll clean deep down, and scuff the surface for paint adhesion.
To redo the flocking (fuzz) inside the compartment, Don Jer Products has a kit for about $25.